The Most Important Factor In An RPG Game

[Showa]

1. Gameplay (Not as much storyline as battle/interaction/ect)
2. Character development (I love fine-tuning and tweaking my stats)
3. Graphics (I don't mean really "1337 3d pwnag3", but charming graphics you can get in to)
4. Storyline (Storyline isn't that much of a deal it me, as long as it doesnt suck horribly)
5. Music (I absolutly hate elevator music, but other than that i dont mind)

 

[rayvyn]

for me personaly are
1- Story
1.5 -Story development
2- Gameplay
2.5 replay value
3 grapphics
4 Sound

 

[like2program]

1. Online play
2. Good story
3. Gamepad(Joystick) support.
4. Catchy name
5. Good graphics
6. Awesome music
7. The ability to roam freely about the world and do mostly what you like.

Sounds like Crysis

 

[hermitobserver]

i think the 3 most important are plot, graphics, and just plain fun. If it doesn't have a good plot, then you are practically wondering around aimlessly. If it has sucky graphics, then why would anyone want to play it. And the most important factor, which is totally an opinon, is is it fun to play. If it's not fun, why play it(other than to look cool).